TinyRC.com

TinyRC.com (http://tinyrc.com/forums/index.php)
-   XMODS Parts and Hop-Ups (http://tinyrc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=126)
-   -   The Ball Differential: LSD, USD, or LGD? (http://tinyrc.com/forums/showthread.php?t=21134)

Turnination Guy 02-03-2005 01:29 AM

The Ball Differential: LSD, USD, or LGD?
 
This weekend, after meeting a friend at F1 Boston (http://www.f1boston.com/), and running in 2 races (man, these things are cramped...), I opened up my XMODS car and gave him a look. My intention was to ask him about something that I had suspected about the ball differential since I bought the AWD kit and opened it up...

My theory was that, since the intersection between the bearing balls in the ball differential and the friction plates is only a single point (between a perfect sphere and a perfect plane, anyway), the plates would be very likely to slip completely away from the bearing balls and under sufficient torque fail to operate as EITHER a locked differential OR an open one; and instead, allow the gears to spin without turning the wheels, and lose all traction. I wanted his opinion because he is a Rally racing fan, a former auto mechanic, and had a relative who worked on Group B cars.

After some fairly simple testing, we concluded that, by the time you had enough torque difference between the left and right wheels to activate the differential function, you very nearly had enough torque to lose all traction altogether.

You can test this yourself by extracting the Ball Differential and the axles.

Hold one wheel steady and then rotate the ball differential. Be aware of how much torque is required to get the other wheel to rotate.

Hold both wheels steady (you may need a vice or a friend to help), and rotate the ball differential. You’ll notice that it didn’t take very much more torque to get the differential to slip past the stationary wheels.

We both tried to give this object a more appropriate name than “Limited Slip Differential”, since it very much wasn’t one. I came up with “Unlimited Slip Differential”, since each side can slip WAY more than it should. He came up with “Limited Grip Differential”, since it almost never has enough grip to act as a differential anyway.

For a look at a real Limited Slip Differential (a Torsen, my favorite), you can look at this one (http://www.sonic.net/garyg/zonc/Tech...ferential.html).

A Limited Slip Differential is only supposed to act as an open differential when there is a difference in the torque applied by the road to the wheels. When there is no torque applied to one wheel, or when equal torque is applied to both wheels, it is supposed to act as locked.

The Torsen differential does this because the normal force that causes friction between all the gears is all but eliminated when there is a difference in torque. The Torsen also has the super-cool feature that, by adjusting the ratio of the slopes of the left helical gears to the right helical gears, you can make one side accelerate away from matched speed FASTER than the other.

We aren’t going to get a Torsen differential; it’s just too complicated for something of our size. But at the same time, we shouldn’t settle for a differential that loses traction worse than an open differential.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:49 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.